Dewey's Garage Inc
A 45+ year Fairport institution — small shop, two ASE-certified mechanics, and a track record of long-tenured repeat customers.
Public ratings
Ratings snapshots collected 2026-05-15. Full review text is published by the original platforms — we link rather than republish.
Public profiles
Services offered
- Oil Change & Multi-Point
- Brake Service
- NYS Safety + Emissions Inspection
- Check Engine + Diagnostics
- Tires
- A/C Service
- Battery Service
Service areas
fairport · east-rochester
About (editorial)
Dewey's Garage has operated at 68 O'Connor Road in Fairport since 1979. It's a small, focused shop with two ASE-certified mechanics on site, and its customer mix skews heavily to people who have been bringing cars there for fifteen or twenty years. They cover oil change, battery, tire, brake inspection, A/C, and check-engine diagnostic work on most makes. Third-party review aggregates land in the 4.8–5.0 range across 70+ reviews, with the recurring pattern being clear pricing, no unnecessary upsells, and customers staying loyal across decades. The shop runs weekdays only — no Saturday hours — which fits its commuter-during-the-week customer base in Fairport and East Rochester.
Small-shop ethic with long-tenured customers — the kind of place people refer their kids to once they start driving.
Sources + verification
Discovered via: Google search 'independent auto repair Fairport NY family owned'
Last verified: 2026-05-15
Confidence: high
Sources consulted: website · yelp